Big Pharma Profits from Grandmother’s Little Helpers

The Kaiser Daily Health Policy Report today summarizes two new studies from the journal Health Affairs, documenting the explosion in the use–and cost–of psychotropic drugs over the last decade. One study found that between 1996 and 2006, “prescriptions for mental health medications increased by 73% among U.S. adults and by 50% among children.”  As of 2006, one in 10 U.S. adults takes at least one prescription for this purpose.

I’ve written before about the growth of antidepressant use among the over-65 crowd (myself included), which seems to be the new way to deal with what a drag it is getting old. But the new study also finds dramatic growth in the use of other medications: “The study found that the number of U.S. seniors receiving psychotropic medications, including dementia and antipsychotic drugs, doubled during that time period.”

This points, in particular, to the increasing treatment of older people with cognitive loss, and any kind of agitated or unruly behavior, as “psychotic.” It’s impossible to know for sure, but I suspect this has something to do with the fact that the drug companies have been pushing their lucrative psychiatric medications on this vulnerable population–the most notorious (and illegal) example being Lilly’s campaign to urge doctors to prescribe the antipsychotic drug Zyprexa for off-label use on elderly patients with dementia.

Unsurprisingly, the second study published in Health Affairs documents a steep rise in spending for mental health care during the same ten-year period–more than 30%, with “nearly all of the increase caused by psychiatric drug costs.” Big Pharma reaps even more rewards from mental health than from other medical fields: “Drugs accounted for 51% of mental health care costs in 2006, while drugs accounted for 26% of spending for all other health care costs, according to national data.” The Kaiser article makes note of the trend toward “greater reliance of the use of psychiatric drugs compared with other forms of psychosocial treatments such as therapist visits.”

This is especially bad news for old timers, since the weakest link in their health coverage isn’t psychotherapy–which Medicare covers pretty generously–but prescription drugs. This is due to the inadequate Medicare Part D program, which was designed to benefit drug and insurance companies at the expense of beneficiaries (and taxpayers). And it turns out that elders with mental health issues get particularly screwed by Part D: A recent study found that on average, we will fall into the infamous “donut hole”–the gap where all coverage for prescriptions ceases–two months earlier than others.

Several reports issued since the recession began have shown that older people simply stop filling some of their prescriptions when they can’t afford them. So what’s going to happen when all us geezers who have come to depend on Big Pharma’s little helpers stop taking our meds?

2 responses to “Big Pharma Profits from Grandmother’s Little Helpers

  1. Just as Jim Ridgeway writes, “unruly or agitated” behavior — or ANY kind of intensely emotional behavior — tends to be categorized as ‘psychotic’ and medicated. Even more striking to a psychotherapist,(like me) is that distress, unhappiness, loss of appetite, etc. is invariably described as a unitary phenomenon — “depression” — and medicated. It’s become almost impossible for therapists NOT to request a medication consultation if a patient feels sad over a period of time. Moreover, in my experience, while some patients benefit from anti-depressants, a lot don’t. But they still feel as if they’re cheating themselves if they “just talk” to a therapist, just spend time trying to understand what’s going on with them.

  2. Nancy Clarkson

    I know the nursing home ‘physician’ where our parents retired to was performing illegal drug interaction experiments on them in return, no doubt, for payments by Big Pharma. We weren’t allowed to receive a list of their medications, but my mother especially has to choke down a full handful, then they so locked up her system she would be in a catatonic condition for hours afterward. We asked a nurse friend of ours to visit during meals-and-pills, she said from what she could identify many of the pills had severe interaction warnings, but she risked getting fired if she supported us, so our only choice was to move our parents to another ‘care’ facility, but the attendants there stole my parents things and beat them both bad when they complained. Something to look forward to when you retire!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s