GOP to the Unemployed: Drop Dead (You Bums)

Tomorrow, unemployment benefits will officially end for hundreds of thousands of Americans, thanks to maneuverings by Senate Republicans to prevent a vote that would have extended those benefits. Unless the extension is passed soon, some 1.1 million of the nation’s unemployed will see their unemployment expire in the coming month, and 5 million will lose benefits by June. 

The House finally voted to extend benefits on Thursday, after several days of stalling and posturing. But in the Senate, the measure was blocked by Kentucky’s Jim Bunning. Politico reported that late into Thursday night, Bunning held out against repeated Democratic attempts to pass the extension by unanimous consent. In response to entreaties from colleagues across the aisle, other Republican senators rose to defend Bunning’s right to obstruct the vote, and Bunning himself was heard to utter, “Tough shit.”  

Bunning said he wanted to see the cost of the benefits offset by other savings, to keep from adding to the deficit. But earlier in the week, Nevada Republican Congressman Dean Heller offered another objection to extending unemployment benefits: He believes it might create a nation of bums.

Think Progress relayed Heller’s remarks, which were made at a Republican Party function in Elko, Nevada, and reported in the local paper:

Heller said the current economic downturn and policies may bring back the hobos of the Great Depression, people who wandered the country taking odd jobs. He said a study found that people who are out of work longer than two years have only a 50 percent chance of getting back into the workforce.

“I believe there should be a federal safety net,” Heller said, but he questioned the wisdom of extending unemployment benefits yet again to a total of 24 months, which Congress is doing. “Is the government now creating hobos?” he asked.

Heller doesn’t seem bothered by the fact that he hails from a state with one of the nation’s highest unemployment rates–now more than 13 percent–as well as its highest foreclosure rate. In his speech, he managed to blame everything on the Democrats. “Six percent of Americans believe the stimulus package created jobs. More Americans believe Elvis is still alive,” he said. Never mind that the extended unemployment benefits Heller derided are in fact among the most effective components the stimulus package, according to the Congressional Budget Office, producing  $1.90 in growth for every $1 spent. 

What makes Heller’s statement really stupid, of course, is that people could become hobos if Congress doesn’t extend unemployment benefits, rather than if they do. Modest as they are, these weekly benefits are what’s keeping thousands–and perhaps millions–of families out of  poverty. The benefits that expire first are for people who have been out of work the longest, and are most likely to be living close to the edge already. 

The same is true for the other social safety net programs that Republicans tend to despise. For example, without Social Security, according to the Alliance for Retired Americans, ”55% of severely disabled workers and their families would live in poverty; 47% of elderly households would live in poverty; another 1.3 million children would fall into poverty; and 2.4 million grandparent-headed households caring for 4.5 million grandchildren would be deprived of [their] most important source of income.” Yet Social Security, too, has long been under attack by conservatives–a position that’s lately gained bipartisan ground, as reflected in Obama’s bipartisan “debt commission,” which is aimed at reducing entitlements.

The heydey of hobos was during the Great Depression, before the New Deal began to weave the social safety net. If Nelson and his fellow Republicans want to see Americans riding the rails, living in tent cities, and lining up at soup kitchens (even more than they already are), all they have to do is keep tearing that safety net apart.


10 responses to “GOP to the Unemployed: Drop Dead (You Bums)

  1. why is this not the fault of the 99 other senators
    Regardless of the arcane senate rule in effect, or that quaint old fashioned thing called “courtesy” if LBJ or, god forbid, N Gingrich were in Reids place, the bill would have passed.
    This is more a comment on the spinelessness of the democrats then the wackoness of the GOP

  2. Pingback: MOVE TO AMEND CORPORATIONS « John Legry's Blog

  3. Pingback: STOP CORPORATE ELITE « John Legry's Blog

  4. So when should the benefits end? This depression is going to last MANY more years. Should people get unemployment for 5-10-20 years? You should get the measure of unemployment commeasurant to what you paid in. Nothing more. Heller & Bunning had a lot of guts to do what they did. Too bad Hilary wasn’t around, they could have asked her to throw a few bucks to the unemployed from the building budget of our new US embassy palace in London. Too bad that bum Bunning is just thinking about the deficit instead of what the people want now. I rather doubt that a few years down the road when our multi-trillion dollar deficit loans get called in, those taxpayers won’t mind getting reamed for decisions made today.

  5. richardabny

    We should stop spending the money on wars for empire and foreign aid, via the government and the Fed and we might have some to help the people.

  6. I’m with ausscyn,unemployed veterans.. what good are they? we should load them on rafts and
    float them into the Atlantic.
    Then they came for the trade unionists but I was
    not a trade unionist so I didn’t speak up.

  7. Don’t forget Republican Sen. Jon Kyl of Arizona who defended Bunning. He thinks continuing unemployment benefits will only serve as “a disincentive for the unemployed to look for work.” But Kyl is VERY concerned about .25% (that’s one quarter of one percent) of the population with estates over seven million who are still subject to estate tax. The other 99.27% of the population are not, but Kyl wanted to hold unemployment benefits hostage until Dems agreed to eliminate all such taxes. There’s only one right word for such a person. Depraved.

  8. Correction: that’s 99.75% of the population that will pay no estate tax under current law.

  9. Jimmy, I just discovered your site and immediately felt right at home . Visit me at and you will see why.

    As one geezer to another I like your style and sincerity although we are at opposite ends of the ideology pole.

  10. I am unemployeed, but diffently not by choise
    I dont like anyone to telling me to drop dead and sayiny that I am a bum…… God well get you,
    and while you are waiting for him you can kiss my ass.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s